Years 1791 to 1839

* 1837-1839	Caleb Earle	St. Johns No. 1P
* 1836	Joshua B. Rathbun	Washington No. 5
* 1833-1835	Joseph S. Cooke	Mount Vernon No. 4
* 1832	Stephen A. Robinson	St.John's No. 1
* 1831	Joseph S. Cooke	Mount Vernon No. 4
* 1829-1830	Barney Merry	Union No. 10
* 1827-1828	Peter Grinnell	Mount Vernon No. 4
* 1825-1826	Richard Anthony	Mount Vernon No. 4
* 1817-1824	John Carlile	St. Johns No. 1P
* 1815-1816	William Wilkinson	St. Johns No. 1P
* 1813-1814	Thomas S. Webb	St. Johns No. 1P
* 1811-1812	Sylvester Child, Jr.	St. Johns No. 1P
* 1809-1810	Ephraim Bowen, Jr.	St. Johns No. 1P
* 1802-1808	Moses Seixas	St. John's No. 1
* 1800-1801	Christopher Olney	St. Johns No. 1P
* 1799	Peleg Clarke	St. John's No. 1
* 1794-1798	Jabez Bowen	St. Johns No. 1P
* 1791-1793	Christopher Champlin	St. John's No. 1